IR Notes 271 - 8 April 2026
www.irshare.eu
 
 
  A question for…
Lidia Gil Otero, PhD Assistant Professor in Labour and Social Security Law at Santiago de Compostela University

In the context of the Digilare (*) project, you advocate using the transposition of the Platform Work Directive, which is due to be completed by the end of 2026, as an opportunity to extend some of the rights granted to platform workers, to all workers. Is that a realistic proposition?
It is of course a political decision, which would involve transposing an EU directive beyond the scope of its minimum requirements, but in our view, it’s important to use the opportunity provided by this transposition to ensure a harmonisation of workers’ rights. We’ve seen that there are differences in understanding, from one country to another, of the information and consultation provisions in the EU’s AI Regulation. We also deplore the existence of dual standards when it comes to the level of protection offered to digital platform workers, who will benefit from robust protection once the directive is transposed, and to other types of workers who are also subject to algorithmic management. The latter will benefit solely from the right to information provided for by the AI Regulation, and only at the time an AI tool is introduced – not during the course of its development or with regard to future impacts on working conditions. So we believe that the rights established by the digital platform workers directive should be transferred to “algorithmic workers”, i.e. those affected by algorithmic management and artificial intelligence tools. Moreover, the European framework directive on informing and consulting employees should also be amended, to include not only consultation at the time AI is introduced into a company, but also during the course of its development, so as to monitor AI’s various impacts on employment and working conditions. We think it would be really opportune to avoid establishing different levels of protection for platform workers and non-platform workers, by opting for an ambitious transposition of the directive, including by standardising the right to recourse to an AI expert as part of the consultation process.


(*) See Digilare project website.

 
  Agenda

 


14 April
Paris
A one-day international seminar organised by the CNAM’s Interdisciplinary Laboratory for Economic Sociology (LISE), on the topic of « Ubérisation, espace public et parties prenantes : vers une nouvelle configuration des relations d’emploi et de travail dans les territoires ? » [‘Uberisation, public space and stakeholders: towards a new configuration of employment and work relationships in the world around us?’]


21 April
Brussels
Eurofound is organising an event to unveil the latest results of its European survey on working conditions: Working in the age of AI – How are working conditions changing across Europe?


24 April
Bordeaux
Conference entitled « Plateformes numériques : enjeux de santé et sécurité au travail » [‘Digital platforms: occupational health and safety issues’], organised by Médecins du Monde and Bordeaux University (Registration).


12 May
Brussels
Conference organised by Business Europe, Responsible Business Alliance (RBA) and MEP Axel Voss, entitled “From Rules to Reality: Driving CSDDD Implementation”.


29 June
Luxembourg
Employment and Social Affairs Council


16 to 18 September
Oslo
Conference organised jointly by IWPLMS and IREC: How can trends towards inequality in the labour market be counteracted and what role can actors and institutions play?

 
  Who we are?

 


IR Notes is a fortnightly newsletter produced by IR Share and its network of experts, and is available in several European languages (English, French, German, Italian, Spanish, Polish). It offers Europe-wide monitoring of employment law, labour relations and employment policy. It is available by subscription for 273 euros per year .


The team: This issue was producaed by Inès Bollet, Victoria Fonseca, Ambre Grenier-Boley, Frédéric Turlan and Iris Turlan. Find out more about the IR Share team on our website.


Subscribe to IR Notes Via the IR Share website or by calling us on: +33 (0)6 81 41 53 95 or
E-mail: frederic.t@irshare.eu


Legal notice. Publisher: IR Share SARL - 5, Les Compères - 89520 Fontenoy, France – Tel.: +33 (0)6 81 41 53 95 – share capital 1,500 euros – commercial register (RCS Auxerre): 512 567 959. Managing editor: Frédéric Turlan. Hosting: ALTEO by Damien Cornillet - Château - 89500 Villeneuve-sur-Yonne. CPPAP no.: 0626 Z 93933.

 
  Follow us on LinkedIn!

Why not connect to the IR Notes LinkedIn page, so that you can keep up with developments in the issues we’re covering, between two editions? You’re welcome to follow us! There are already 808 of you following us!

 

IR Share is a privately- owned, independent, apolitical company whose aim is to inform and assist all players involved in social dialogue within and outside Europe. It has been the correspondent organisation for France of the European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions since 2009.

 

Lead story
Is pay transparency the new enemy to be targeted?

After seeing off the corporate sustainability reporting and due diligence directives, Member States appear ready to tackle the pay transparency directive, which is due to be transposed in Member States by 7 June 2026. Not only are many countries behind schedule, but a growing number of them are expressing open hostility to the directive, either by calling for its annulment, as Sweden has done, or indirectly, by delaying its implementation, as countries like France and the Netherlands have done, some of them in the hope that the European Parliament will revise this directive within the framework of a forthcoming Omnibus directive. With the transposition deadline now just a couple of months away, the situation is becoming somewhat chaotic. Officially, the European Commission is holding firm, and has announced on several occasions that it will not postpone that date. Recently, when unveiling the Gender Equality Strategy 2026-2030, the Commission pointed out that in the EU, on average, women still earn 12% less per hour than men (see press release). Consequently, “tackling this is a matter of righting an injustice and delivering on the EU Treaties and the Charter of Fundamental Rights”. And to this end, “the pay transparency directive is a game changer for tackling pay discrimination and the undervaluation of female-dominated jobs, which are root causes of the gender pay gap.” The Commission explains that it “will continue to support Member States in the effective and timely implementation of this Directive”. In other words, it is not about to change course, and if the directive is not duly transposed by the appointed time, it will trigger the usual procedures against Member States, even extending to prosecution by the Court of Justice if necessary. Nevertheless, on 26 March, the Swedish government, which voted against the text in 2023, launched hostilities, declaring that the “formulation” of the directive “is administratively much too cumbersome and therefore risks diminishing the gains achieved in terms of equality”. The government therefore “intends to work towards a postponement of the directive’s implementation date and a renegotiation of the directive, aimed at simplifying the regulations”. The end of the press release is very clear: “the government does not intend, at the present time, to submit a draft law to Parliament concerning the pay transparency directive” (see press release). This government position, which is being pushed by the far-right Sweden Democrats party, will no doubt delight the employers’ organisations, which are calling for at least a pause in the implementation of this directive. The argument is always the same: “we agree with the goal that has been set, but the text imposes a bureaucratic nightmare”. Yet the fact remains that a large majority of Member States and the European Parliament voted in favour of this so-called bureaucratic nightmare three years ago. Once again, as Roland Erne, Professor of European Integration and Employment Relations at University College Dublin notes, to take these steps is “to defy both the rule of law and democracy in the European Union”. It therefore seems that a growing number of actors now regard an EU directive as something that can be campaigned against not only before its adoption, but also afterwards, during the transposition phase. The same goes for the revised EWC directive, which will undoubtedly be attacked on all sides during the transposition phase. In the case of pay transparency, Sweden’s attempt to hold up the directive’s progress looks set to remain a symbolic gesture. Non-transposition does not constitute effective immunisation against the directive: the Commission will be able to bring infringement proceedings against Sweden, and any fine imposed by the Court of Justice may be large enough to act as a deterrent and make it change its mind. As for the directive, some of its provisions might be deemed to have a direct effect, thus enabling any Swedish citizen seeking justice to invoke them before their domestic courts. It should be borne in mind that the EU’s goal is to seek harmonisation, and it has the necessary legal tools at its disposal to prevent Member States picking and choosing among its legislation, i.e. to deter what the British call “cherry picking”.


1. European Union
Social update

Social policy : On 9 March, the Council adopted the Joint Employment Report, which examines the progress made by Member States in the area of social convergence. The report examines the labour market and social policies of each country, evaluates their performance and compiles the results at EU level, so that they can be compared with the objectives set at this level. The EU is currently well on the way to achieving its overall objective in terms of employment rates by 2030. The EU’s employment rate reached 75.8% in 2024 (up 0.5 point on 2023), so it is only 2.2 points off the 78% target set for 2030. On the other hand, the situation is mediocre when it comes to two other targets: 1/ the proportion of adults taking part in apprenticeship activities each year rose from 37.4% in 2016 to 39.5% in 2022. Progress is slow and the rate achieved remains more than 20 points below the EU’s main target for 2030, which is set at 60%. 2/ Despite significant progress, further efforts will be needed to reach the target of reducing poverty, which fell by around 2.9 million people in the EU in 2024, compared to 2019. However, this result “remains far from the EU headline target of a reduction by at least 15 million by 2030”. What is worrying is that the number of people at risk of poverty was higher in 2024 than in 2019 in 11 Member States.



Social economy : On 30 March, the European Commission published a report on implementation of the action plan for the social economy, adopted on 9 December 2021. The Commission emphasises that “between 2021 and the end of 2025, 21 Member States had either adopted or were preparing national or regional strategies for the social economy. Furthermore, 12 Member States had adopted or reformed social economy laws”. Nevertheless, the communication admits that “the social economy is still not recognised or supported consistently across Member States and regions”. The social economy is still suffering from “an uneven playing field, which is exacerbated by its distinct business model” (see press release).



Pay transparency : On 27 March, the European Institute for Gender Equality (EIGE) published guidelines on gender-neutral job evaluation and classification, which will be useful for the purposes of the pay transparency directive. Alongside this toolkit, the EIGE and Eurofound have worked together on drafting a policy brief, which sets out in detail the benefits of gender-neutral job evaluation for employers, employees and social partners alike.



Psychosocial risks : On 25 March, MEP Estelle Ceulemans (S&D) filed her draft legislative own-initiative report on psychosocial risks at work, in which she calls on the Commission to put forward, by the end of 2026, a proposal for a directive on work-related psychosocial risks, including minimum requirements with a view to an equivalent, high level of protection for all workers in the Union. Recommendations, in the form of a proposal for a directive, appear in an annex to the report.


Case law

Religious conviction : On 12 March, the Court of Justice handed down a judgment concerning a female employee of an association that forms part of the German Catholic Church and provides counselling to pregnant women. The employee decided to leave the Church (so that she would no longer have to pay an additional church levy). When the association learnt of her decision, it decided to dismiss her, accusing her of a serious breach of her loyalty obligations. The Court of Justice holds that in principle, the employer was not entitled to dismiss the employee on the sole ground that she had left the Catholic Church, given that this association also employs non-Catholics to carry out the same activity, and deems that counsellors should merely be required to undertake to adhere to the precepts of the Catholic Church. The Court of Justice therefore views the rule preventing an employee from leaving this church during the course of the employment relationship, on pain of dismissal, as a breach of EU law (see press release).


2. Member States
Germany

Stricter rules for public procurement contracts : On 27 March, Parliament definitively adopted the law designed to “strengthen free collective bargaining rules by guaranteeing that collective labour agreements will be adhered to when federal public procurement contracts are placed” (Tariftreuegesetz). It provides that companies performing these contracts must ensure that employees’ working conditions are equivalent to those stipulated in their collective agreements (see press release). The aim is to increase the number of employees who are covered by collective agreements. This law has been criticised by the trade unions, who believe that it is still not enough, as it applies to only two thirds of public procurement contracts, and establishes numerous exceptions and waivers, such as excluding those signed with the armed forces (see press release). The new law has also been criticised by the employers, on the grounds of increased bureaucracy and concerns about its impact on the costs of public procurement (see press release).



An alliance to defend the welfare state : In the face of fears of economic crises and attacks on democracy, fourteen organisations, including NGOs and trade unions, have launched an alliance to promote a strong and sustainable welfare state (see press release). In their view, the State is not an obstacle, but a model for prosperity and sustainability (see press release). The alliance is structured around several objectives: securing a properly financed social security system, guaranteeing quality work, combatting poverty and protecting the climate. The alliance, which represents more than 20 million members, uses a YouGov study revealing support for the welfare state among a majority of the population, to make its case (see study).


Belgium

Carers’ leave : The maximum leave allowance for “informal carers” will be doubled for employees who apply for it from 1 July onwards, under the law of 22 March 2026, published on 1 April, which makes a number of changes to the legislation applicable to carers. The maximum term for full suspension of a contract of employment will rise from 3 to 6 months, while the maximum permitted length of a switch to part-time working will rise from 6 to 12 months. The law also offers greater flexibility when it comes to taking this leave, by allowing carers to take it over a shorter period in order to meet their needs, subject to the employer’s agreement (see press release).


Spain

Monitoring working time : The law on mandatory monitoring of working hours is being changed by an amendment to Article 34.9 of the Labour Code, which requires all forms of monitoring of working time to be conducted exclusively by electronic means. This change is directly linked to Royal decree-law 8/2019 of 8 March 2019, which made such registration of working hours mandatory for all companies. The amendment stipulates that the labour inspectorate authorities must be able to access these registers remotely. The measure will enter into force 20 days after its publication in the Official Journal, although the publication date has not yet been announced. However, the amendment has not received unanimous approval. On 23 March, the Council of State published a non-binding consultative opinion expressing reservations regarding the Ministry of Labour’s planned measure. Among the arguments formulated by its critics are: the cost for employers of introducing an electronic system, the absence of any impact assessment performed with regard to public authorities that are also affected by the law, risks linked to protection of workers’ data, and the fact that these regulations would go further than what is required by law. The CEOE, which is one of the main employers’ organisations, has welcomed the Council of State’s opinion.


Malta

Violence in the workplace : Draft law no. 166, adopted on 3 March, aims to enhance employees’ working conditions. It sets out the definitions of Article 29 relative to sexual harassment in the workplace, by distinguishing it from other types of harassment. The text also adds an Article 29A, which punishes any acts of violence and/or harassment in the workplace. In addition, the definition of the employment relationship is broadened to include trainees, volunteers, persons whose employment contract has been terminated and job applicants. In short, it now covers anyone involved in a working environment, whether or not they are bound by a traditional link of subordination. This law aims to strengthen protection of workers against any type of violence – be it physical, moral, sexual or psychological – that they might encounter in a work setting.


3. Companies

Negotiating the creation of a European Works Council : The management of French container shipping company CMA-CGM is pursuing a negotiation aimed at establishing a EWC at group level, at its own initiative, after purchasing two logistics companies whose employees were previously covered by a European body: a EWC in the case of CEVA Logistics employees and the joint works council of the Bolloré group’s European companies, which covered Bolloré Logistics, the entity purchased by CMA-CGM. The aim is to establish a EWC at group level in place of the existing bodies. At the study day devoted to European Works Councils, organised in Paris on 31 March by the CFE-CGC confederation, Capucine Edou, the CFE-CGC negotiator on the 41-member Special Negotiating Body (SNB) , noted the difficult points involved in this negotiation, which is expected to be completed by the summer. She highlighted the discussion regarding the number of members who will sit on the future EWC (which lasted for months), and the confidential nature of the information in question. Returning to the matter of the expert accompanying the SNB, Capucine Edou called for vigilance, “as we have on occasions seen this person take the place of the negotiators (…), with the resulting risk of seeing consensus positions – previously arrived at with great difficulty – unravel. For example, SNB members had managed to secure agreement to a request for 50/50 parity on the EWC but the coordinator then revised the ratio to 40/60 in the name of compliance with the directive.” (see other participants’ interventions in the summary of the day’s proceedings).


4. Studies and reports

Psychosocial risks : A new report prepared by Eurogip, an observatory of the occupational risks branch of France's state-run public health insurance system L’Assurance Maladie, examines the instruments existing at international level in terms of psychosocial risk (PSR) prevention. It then provides an overview of prevention regulations and instruments existing at EU level, followed by a national analysis of seven European countries (Belgium, Denmark, France, Germany, Italy, Spain and Sweden) and five non-European countries (Australia, Canada, Japan, South Korea and the USA). The report also describes some of the PSR assessment tools used in a corporate environment, guides and information materials, national campaigns, initiatives and networks, good practices, calls for projects, and some of the financial incentives and support available.

 


Désabonnement