 |
| |
IR Notes 211 - 28 June 2023
www.irshare.eu |
|
|
| |
| |
A question for… Loïc Lerouge, holder of the International Research Chair in Comparative Studies on Occupational Health (CIECST)(*)
The Commission has issued a communication on mental health, without moving forward on the issue of preparing a specific directive on psychosocial risks. Hasn’t the time come to act? This subject is a complicated and delicate one, not only in political terms, but also for employers, because we’re taking the issue of health to the collective level, which means having to talk about work management. Bear in mind that in 2004 and 2007, European social partners separated the issue of workplace stress from that of harassment and violence at work, in the context of negotiating two European agreements, without mentioning psychosocial risks. This shows how difficult this subject can be, and how it requires us to play for time, so that we can lay sound foundations and convince politicians of the need to move up a notch and address psychosocial risks. Consequently, I’m not shocked by the fact that we’re proceeding in stages and taking the time to set things in stone properly, rather than moving forward too quickly and not achieving anything in the end (e.g. the draft directive on musculoskeletal disorders, which never saw the light of day) or instruments that are poorly drafted or conceived, and would in the end be hard to implement or unconvincing for stakeholders. So, there are several possible strategies now. The first one, which is what the Commission has done, is to include the term “psychosocial risks” in a directive that is in the process of being adopted, such as the one intended to protect platform workers. However, this is not a convincing move, as it doesn’t allow us to define either the concepts or the preventive mechanisms. The second one is to revise the 1989 framework directive. This however already states that the employer must prevent occupational health risks in all work-related aspects of life. The risk of revising this progressive directive is that we will weaken it and deprive it of the status of framework directive, by incorporating specific risks into it. The Commission may well also take the view that psychosocial risks are a matter for social partners and for collective bargaining. The difficulty lies in the risk of creating an instrument that is not ambitious enough to satisfy all parties, but would also be hard to apply in practice. This is a matter for social dialogue with a view to “applying” a directive and not one for social dialogue with a view to “replacing” a directive. The final strategy, which would perhaps be the best one, is to supplement the 1989 framework directive with a specific “daughter directive” covering psychosocial risks, and fixing the definitions, so that we know what we’re talking about, and laying down the prevention principles. It would take on the role of defining the road to be followed and the direction to be taken by Member States, in terms of preventing and addressing psychosocial risks. If it looks like a regulatory instrument will be necessary, then we must take our time to convince everyone of the need for this and to draft it properly, so that the subject isn’t handled at too superficial a level.
(*) Loïc Lerouge is also Research Director at the French National Centre for Scientific Research (CNRS), a member of the Centre for Comparative Labour and Social Security Law (COMPTRASEC, UMR 5114 CNRS-Université de Bordeaux), and a specialist in occupational health (CIECST).
|
|
|
 |
|
|
 |
| |
Who we are?
IR Notes is a fortnightly newsletter produced by IR Share and its network of experts, and is available in several European languages (English, French, German, Italian, Spanish). It offers Europe-wide monitoring of employment law, labour relations and employment policy. It is available by subscription for 18 euros per month .
The team This issue was producaed by Pedrag Bejakovic, Sylvain Nadalet, Pascale Turlan and Frédéric Turlan. Find out more about the IR Share team on our website.
Subscribe to IR Notes Via the IR Share website or by calliang us on: +33 (0)6 81 41 53 95 or E-mail: frederic.t@irshare.eu
Legal notice. Publisher: IR Share SARL - 5, Les Compères - 89520 Fontenoy, France – Tel.: +33 (0)6 81 41 53 95 – share capital 1,500 euros – commercial register (RCS Auxerre): 512 567 959. Managing editor: Frédéric Turlan. Hosting: ALTEO by Damien Cornillet - Château - 89500 Villeneuve-sur-Yonne. CPPAP no.: 0626 Z 93933.
|
|
|
 |
| |
Follow us on LinkedIn! Why not connect to the IR Notes LinkedIn page, so that you can keep up with developments in the issues we’re covering, between two editions? You’re welcome to follow us! There are already 300 of you following us!
|
|
|
 |
| |
European Industrial Relations Dictionary In case reading IR Notes inspires you to explore this subject further, we are providing links to the European Industrial Relations Dictionary published by Eurofound. This is updated at regular intervals by IR Share, which publishes IR Notes. The term definitions are available in English and can easily be converted into other languages using on-line translation tools.
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
Lead story
The Commission wants to improve workplace mental health without introducing a directive
On 7 June, the European Commission issued a communication on a comprehensive approach to mental health. Its aim is to “put mental health on a par with physical health” and “ensure a new, cross-sectoral approach to mental health issues” (see press release). The Commission explains, via this text, that it is responding “to the call for action from the European Parliament following its resolution from 2022 on mental health in the digital world of work” (see IR Notes 190). The Commission addresses the subject of mental health at work in its strategic framework on health and safety at work (see IR Notes 182 and Strategic Framework on Health and Safety at Work)). It states that “27% of workers have reported experiencing work-related stress, depression, or anxiety during the previous twelve months, which increases the chances of absenteeism with serious impact on workers’ lives and business organisation”. It acknowledges that it is necessary to “reflect on the way forward as regards the right to disconnect”, with the aim of reducing stress and promoting “a better work-life balance”, and the right “to return to work after mental illness” and to a “psychologically safe working environment”. On the first point, it will continue to “support social partners in their endeavour to negotiate a new agreement on telework and the right to disconnect”, which is due to be concluded at the next negotiation meeting, on 10 July. The right to return to work is due to be addressed in 2024 by means of a publication based on good practices laid down by the European Agency for Safety and Health at Work (EU-OSHA). Mental health will also be covered by two EU-OSHA “Healthy Workplaces” campaigns: Safe and healthy work in the digital age (2023-2025) and Psychosocial risks and mental health at work (2026-2027/2028). As for a legislative initiative, such as a directive covering psychosocial risks, which Parliament and the European Economic and Social Committee have been calling for, the Commission remains very cautious: it announces its intention to “conduct a peer review on legislative and enforcement approaches to address psychosocial risks at work in the Member States with a view, and subject to its outcomes and the input of social partners, to present an EU-level initiative on the psychosocial risks in the medium term”. This is a paradoxically mild form of words for tackling a phenomenon that has a “serious impact” on workers and companies.
|
1. European Union
Social update
Remuneration of traineeships : While the European Commission is planning to update the 2014 Quality Framework for Traineeships (see IR Notes 200 and Traineeship), on 14 June, MEPs passed, by a large majority (404 votes in favour, 78 against and 130 abstentions), a resolution in favour of strengthening this framework and preparing a directive. This should “ensure minimum quality standards, including rules on the duration of the traineeships, access to social protection” – especially health insurance, unemployment benefits and pension contributions – “as well as remuneration that ensures a decent standard of living in order to avoid exploitative practices”. The proposal for a directive appended to the resolution also provides for an obligation to enter into a traineeship agreement specifying the remuneration to be provided to the trainee in accordance with Directive (EU) 2022/2041 of 19 October 2022 on adequate minimum wages in the EU, and learning objectives, in order to help the trainee acquire practical experience and relevant skills. “The ball is now in the European Commission’s court” says the European Trade Union Confederation’s new Confederal Secretary, Tea Jarc, “and young people will expect them to finally end the scandal of unpaid internships” (see press release). The European Youth Forum, which has launched a campaign to ban unpaid internships, says: “All eyes are on the European Commission now to put an ambitious EU directive on the table” (see press release). The European Tech and Industry sector employers’ organisation (Ceemet) warned before the vote that “there is no legal basis to call for a binding instrument in this area” (see press release). In an Opinion on the Equal Treatment of Young People in the Labour Market, published on 14 June, the European Economic and Social Committee argues that “longer term internships, analogous to work done by paid employees, should be paid”.
> See also: Recommendation concerning quality apprenticeships, recently adopted at the 111th session of the ILO’s International Labour Conference (see press release).
|
Spanish Presidency of the EU : On 1 July, the EU’s rotating Presidency will transfer from Sweden to Spain, which will hold it until the year-end. Spain’s programme, drawn up by a government that may be ousted at the forthcoming elections on 23 July, which are being held early, contains a social chapter (see Presidency website). The Presidency plans to ensure “that the wealth generated benefits all citizens and serves to improve their opportunities and living standards”. It emphasises that “We need a more competitive economy, but also a fairer and more caring one”. The Presidency wants to push for “the extension of workers' rights in several areas”, which it will set out in more detail in the near future. It is likely to tackle the issues of workplace health and safety – the theme of one of the conferences being run by the Presidency – and of democracy at work.
|
- Social progress : On 14 June, the European Economic and Social Committee approved an opinion on the Social Progress Protocol, which was proposed in the final report of the May 2022 Conference on the Future of Europe and was supported by the European Parliament (resolution of 9 June 2022). The aim is to add this protocol to the Treaties, in order to ensure that fundamental social rights are effectively protected in the event of conflict with economic freedoms. This text also seeks to guarantee “respect for the autonomy of the social partners and the proper functioning of national social dialogue [...] systems” and the ”promotion and protection of the highest standards of social rights”.
|
Restructuring : On 6 June, the European Commission issued a proposal for the European Globalisation Adjustment Fund to make a €2.2 million payment to support 600 workers dismissed by Logistics Nivelles ITS, a Belgian subsidiary of the international transport and logistics company Kuehne+Nagel. The latter has closed its site in the Wallonia region and plans to concentrate its operations at Kontich, in the Flanders region. The Commission’s justification for this proposal is that the workers in question are low-skilled and mostly aged 50 years and older, so their chances of finding work tend to be low (press release).
|
Sectoral social dialogue
Telecommunications : European social partners in the telecommunications sector have published a Joint Statement on Remote Work, accompanied by a set of non-binding Guidelines on Remote Work, for use in implementing remote work practices via social dialogue at local level. This statement, which precedes the agreement due to be concluded on 10 July at cross-industry level, is supplemented by a set of guidelines. These guidelines advocate that “the employer, with agreement from the trade unions and employee representatives, should provide all workers with clear and detailed remote working information, and should complete a health and safety assessment related to the remote work, including physical and mental health risks, a risk mitigation plan, and regular monitoring and updating of plans”. Remote workers are “entitled to the same rest periods, hours of work, time recording, holidays and leave as office/worksite-based employees, and to a general right to disconnect outside contractual working hours (…)” (see press releases).
|
Catering industry : On 19 June, European social partners in the catering industry issued a Joint Declaration on “Public Procurement and Collective Bargaining”, calling for a revision of the directive on public procurement. They denounce the fact that “half of the public tenders in Europe are awarded based solely on the lowest price”, thereby incentivising some bidders “to engage in unfair competition and ignore social criteria”. The signatories propose excluding both the lowest price criterion and the obligation requiring companies bidding for public contracts to adhere to collective agreements, in order to promote collective bargaining through public procurement (see press release).
> Find out more: Access to the European Commission’s Social dialogue texts database
|
2. Member States
Croatia
Pension reform : The government has announced that it is planning to reduce the monthly basis used for calculating state pension contributions based on intergenerational solidarity (HZMO). For example, on gross wages and salaries of up to 700 euros, a pension contribution will be payable on the first 400 euros only. This means employees would receive a higher net wage, there would be no increase in the total employer’s contributions, and the future pension payable would be calculated on the previous basis. The government would cover the difference with transfers from the State’s central budget to the pension scheme (see memorandum written in English for IR Notes by our Croatian correspondent).
|
Denmark
Work permit : The Danish Trade Union Confederation FH is concerned at the government’s announcement of a relaxation of the law on employing foreigners, which will allow Danish companies to recruit foreigners for 15 working days twice every 6 months, without applying for a work permit. The aim is to allow large companies to recruit specialised employees for a short period of time with less bureaucracy. However, FH fears that these companies will abuse the system, which will allow them to apply working conditions that are incompatible with the standards in place in Denmark (see press release).
|
Spain
A study of general use of time : On 16 June, the Minister of Employment, Yolanda Díaz, unveiled a study of the general use of time and the rationalisation of work timetables, to be used as the basis for future legislation. This study is intended to guarantee the right to a more balanced use of working people’s time, by reducing the “time discomfort” suffered by many workers, and thereby enhancing their quality of life and reducing their “time poverty” (i.e. not having enough time for oneself). “The current culture and way in which time is organised don’t allow people to rest properly, and these issues affect our physical and emotional health”, says Yolanda Diaz. “If we want to improve our health, we need to rationalise our working hours”. The study proposes 22 measures, such as reducing working hours, limiting the length of intervals between work periods on the same day, establishing a weekly two-day rest period, introducing the right to have flexible or personalised work timetables, drawing up plans in conjunction with employee representatives to enhance the ways in which working hours are organised and time is used; and endeavouring to avoid night-time work and shift work (see press release).
|
Italy
Amendments to social legislation : Decree-law no. 48/2023 of 4 May is the Meloni government’s first legislative act devoted to employment relationships (other than a handful of provisions inserted into the 2023 Finance Law). Although it in no way represents a general overhaul of labour law, this instrument nevertheless intervenes on a number of points of law governing employment relationships, workplace safety, labour market rules, incentives to recruit workers, mechanisms for sanctioning employers and lastly a social security chapter, which provides for the end of “citizenship income” and replaces it with an “inclusion allowance” in 2024. One of the key measures concerns yet another change to the legislation governing fixed-term contracts, which for the past 20 years, has been viewed by all new governments as a flagship project. The new rules introduce a relaxation of the terms applicable to renewing fixed-term contracts after 12 months (during this initial term, no justification is required). The right to extend or renew a fixed-term contract after a one-year period has, since 2018, been subject to certain requirements (of a temporary or exceptional nature, as fixed by law), but the new rule leaves the definition of the grounds for using fixed-term contracts to the wording appearing in branch or company-level collective agreements. The instrument states that if there is no agreement applicable within the company, any renewal or extension of a fixed-term contract will have to meet certain technical, economic or organisational requirements stipulated by the parties in the contract of employment.
|
4. Companies
Transnational collective bargaining
Transnational agreements are back : Transnational agreement negotiations seem to be regaining their vitality. The car-maker Stellantis has begun to negotiate an international framework agreement with IndustriAll Global Union. At Generali, the European Works Council has persuaded management to start negotiating a European agreement on inclusion and diversity, with UNI Europa. The BNP Paribas EWC is currently negotiating a revision of the charter on teleworking signed in 2021. Two European agreement negotiations will follow one another at Suez: one on health and safety at work, and the other on workplace gender equality. At Safran, the negotiation of a European agreement on youth integration and employment commenced in April and will resume in September. A European negotiation on social dialogue at Clariane (formerly Korian) is due to come to an end in September. Lastly, on 17 June, the bank Société Générale renewed its global agreement on group employees’ rights (see press release).
|
European skills observatory : As provided for by the European agreement on development of skills and career paths, signed in 2021 by and between Safran and IndustriAll Europe (see IR Notes 166), the European skills observatory met three times in 2022 and is due to meet a further three times this year (rather than once, as stipulated by the agreement). At these meetings, management presents its medium-term HR plan for career and skills development, and vocational specialisations that are experiencing difficulties or are at risk. Corinne Schievene (CFDT union), who is an observatory member and the group’s EWC secretary, comments: “We have secured the right to invite internal experts to talk to us about issues that impact on employment.” The observatory has been able to hear an expert on the group’s climate strategy, and an AI expert will give a presentation at its next meeting. “This observatory provides us with access to information and data that we never received at EWC level”, says Corinne Schievene, with satisfaction.
|
|
|